Friday, July 24, 2009
By Tom Andersen
< > This Fine Piece of Water - An Environmental History of Long Island SoundAbout Sphere & Tom Andersen
This is a blog about environmental issues in the New York area in general and Long Island Sound in particular. I'm the author of "This Fine Piece of Water: An Environmental History of Long Island Sound," which came out in 2002. I wrote about the environment and other issues during almost two decades as a newspaper reporter.
E-mail me
Tandersen54@optonline.net
Unless you tell me otherwise, I'll assume it's OK to publish what you send me.
Modern Houses
What's Been Happening Lately on the Broadwater Issue?
Talks, Lectures, Speeches
Click here for information about public appearances.About Sphere
We write and publish Sphere on our own time and in a personal capacity, and the views and opinions do not represent the views and opinions of any other organizations we work or write for. We are solely responsible for the content and are not paid for our work (although we might like to be). In short, blame us, no one else.
About The Comments
Our Policy on Anonymous CommentsOther Writings by Tom Andersen
Tom Andersen: WritingsPrevious Posts
- Don't Swim in West Haven
- Governor's Island vs. Davids Island
- Shellfish in Rhode Island
- True As Far As It Goes...
- Spicebush Swallowtail
- Blight
- Marine Mammals
- Still Good
- Terrapins on the Runway
- Pictures of Petrels
Links
- Tom Andersen: Writings
- Long Island Sound Study
- Save the Sound
- SoundWaters
- Soundkeeper
- Broadwater
- Anti-Broadwater Coalition
- Long Island Sound LNG Task Force
- Wading River Civic Association
- Friends of the Bay (Oyster Bay)
- Water Quality, Winds, Waters Temps: MySound
- Long Island Sound Foundation
- Atlantic Coast Watch
- DEP Hypoxia Maps
- Long Island Sound Resource Center
- Connecticut Fund for the Environment
- Citizens Campaign for the Environment
- Tides: Connecticut
- Tides: New York
- New London-Orient Point Ferry
- LI Ferries
- Bridgeport-Port Jefferson Ferry
- Green Guru Network
- Michael Pollan
- Philip Johnson's Glass House
- Fairfield County Child
- AllGreen
- Dot Earth/Andy Revkin
- SoundBounder
- Farmer's Daughter
- Connecticut Yankee
- Energy Outlook
- Grist
- Real Climate
- 70.8%
- 10,000 Birds
- DC Birding Blog
- Bootstrap Analysis
- Walking the Berkshires
- Hungry Hyaena
- Connecticut Smart Growth
- The Blue Marble
- Poof ‘n’Whiffs
- NYLCV's Ecopolitics Daily
- Enviropolitics Blog
- Environmental Headlines from Chris Zurcher
- Katonah Green
2 Comments:
I don't have a problem with tournaments as long as all the fish is eaten and put to good use, although I certainly promote the idea and Catch 'n' Release.
The problem with "meat fishing tournaments" is that so much fish are killed to be weighed, and often left abandoned. Shark tournaments are the worst, since most species are practically inedible. I am surprised they are allowed much anymore, as pelagic shark like off Montauk are becoming quite depleted.
The problem is, the larger fish that get the prizes at the weight station on the dock have the highest concentrations of mercury and other toxins. Smallish to medium sized ones are much better on the table, such as roasted or smoked New England style.
I guess I have lost my taste for all fishing tournaments. Being able to release a marlin, shark, or other big fish and keeping it alive is really a blast if you can afford it. We even tag some if we have the fisheries tags. I've known grown men to cry if their fish dies from the fight.
sam
Inedible is really most a matter of preparation for both taste and toxins. If proper arrangements were made exotic restaurants would use all the fish caught. However, most home chefs prefer fish that are quick and easy prepared without danger to health or spoiled dinner.
But you are right. Generally the sole reason for large predator fish tournaments is as a planned kill semi-extinction event...in hopes of favoring other more commonly enjoyed commercial and sports fish.
But looking at natural extinction over periods in excess of a few million years, I have no problems with this practice. Ecological tragedy is primarily a case of a shortsighted view limited to a human lifetime or that of a nation...basically nostalgia connected to one's own mortally.
Post a Comment
<< Home